PCHeintz72 wrote:Hmmm... I fail to see why he could not do both. That is assuming he would want to, of course, as I doubt they would wish to make him resentful.
Resentful of what, denying him something he's never had?
PCHeintz72 wrote:1. Per your own words, it would be 'every few days'. Most normal males can do it more than that.
The resulting product contain a reduced quantity of the active ingredient. They want the maximum yield of active ingredient. There is a large difference between servicing a woman, and impregnating her.
PCHeintz72 wrote:2. Again, on the assumption they would not want to make him resentful of them, I doubt they would deny him anything as long as they could insure he did not die or hurt his procreative abilities.
We are talking about Ranma here? The guy who lets anyone with authority boss him around? If he'd let his father select who he has to marry, he'd probably let the Emperor of Japan convince him to cooperate. You're also assuming he has any first-hand knowledge of the act, rather than just the speculation of his classmates.
You're also neglecting the method used to procure the sample.
PCHeintz72 wrote:3. They could most likely hardly stop him were they to try without risking affecting him in ways that would ruin his abilities of procreation.
They could easily use psychological pressure. He doesn't have the Western mindset that he's entitled to do what he wants.
PCHeintz72 wrote:4. Does not that then sort of negate the purpose of the story.
Nope, they'd have to explain everything you take for granted he knows. I suspect he's quite naive in that regard.
Think about it, his father is always talking about being manly, and only had one kid, where weepy Soun has three.
Innortal wrote:I just find it funny for the person who has to explain to Ranma how he is supposed to give them the samples.
Waking him up every few words would be the main problem, initially.
MacShimi wrote:Daniel,
Seriously: read the 'Yellow Emperor’s Classic of Internal Medicine' and read a few other reputable books on Chinese medicine. You'll see what I mean. It's impossible for Ranma to not know the things I'm speaking about, he'd have to at least mention them. If you’re happier reading a fictionalised account, read ‘Tales of a Wandering Taoist’ by Deng Min Dao. This is the sort of background that Ranma had when growing up, so it’s really strange seeing him react in such a westernised manner.
Ranma wouldn't mention them in this story because initially he was in ignorance of why he was being held and kept as a female. He was cutting down on his
martial arts activities not to enhance his
marital arts abilities, but because the Emperor and Empress of Japan asked/begged him too. That's answer enough for Ranma. Besides, he was female during this entire time.
Then he was terrified that his mother would kill him.
Then he was frightened that Akane would kill him.
Finally when he might had started thinking about it, he was busy being unconscious.
There was never a time in this fic when it would come up. If there was a following chapter, then it might occur.
pspinler wrote:What I'd wonder W.R.T. this plot is: wouldn't Ryoga, Taro, and Mousse all be candidates for the same treatment Ranma got? If I recall, this only sterilized male *humans*. (If it sterilized all male mammals, this world would face a lot more problems ...)
-- Pat
B'man wrote:Essentially, Pat, Ranma was female when the problems started, and somehow the guv realised what was happening and the enormity of it (don't ask me how) and intercepted her before she changed back. We can assume that the other curse-bearers had spent some time in their male human form before they could be found and thus had been affected.
Ryoga and Mousse might have been given the choice to serve alongside Ranma, and were unwilling to let Ranma live. If the powers that be had a choice between Ranma, who can be swayed by reason or tears, and two who were unwilling to budge, they get rid of the threat to their best candidate. It would be too much of a risk that the three of them would kill each other or destroy their usefulness. Taro probably would have been a guy before the authorities could get to him (he doesn't live in one of the largest cities on Earth like the rest of the cast).