Zwzn wrote:And yet never seems to use said superhuman strength.
Well, sure. Hand to hand isn't her forte. She's better off slinging magic around in youma battles--why the heck
should she go in and mix it up with fistcuffs?
It doesn't change the fact that, in that situation where she
was forced to use superhuman strength, she was able to.
Don't the senshi go to the Moon at one point in season 1, and walk as if on the Earth?
Never saw the episode, so I can't say.
If they did, then the correlating question to that that you'd also want to ask is whether anyone in any of the Moon Kingdom flashbacks--particularly anyone not in a Senshi form--ever
did move in Moon-realistic gravity. The answer to that would give an indication as to whether the gravity effect was in fact localized to the Senshi, or just part of a general life-support system. (Or just laziness on the part of the animators.)
The crystal seems to me at least to be a capasitor basicly in season 2 at least. It draws energy from the other senshi to power it's user(Usagi). The other senshi tend to recover quickly after being drained by it.
Even if it
can function in that way, it very obviously has significant power of it's own--it's used against Beryl before the dead Senshi even start to pitch in, and having two crystals turns the tables against Wiseman, which would make no sense whatsoever if they were just channels.
So again: do we have any evidence that suggests she was drawing from the other Senshi
in that particular scene?A senshi over estamating her power is not unheard of, and Luna is known for having a swiss cheese memory for a reason. Mars could have been counting on the fuel for all we know. I didn't that jets aren't kept fueled until this thread. I personally don't trust summaries
Well, it obviously isn't conclusive one way or the other. Like I said, I personally doubt she was counting on hitting the fuel tank, since A) she never said anything to indicate she was and more importantly B) unless she's knows a lot more about passenger jets than I would imagine the average 14-year old to know, I doubt she'd know where to aim.
But granted, even in the best case it only suggests the capability, not definitively proves it.
That speeks rather poorly for thew senshi, and rather well for the NWC
How do you figure that? At the worst it's only neutral--and to me it gives the implication that the Senshi are at least roughly in Ranma's ballpark in terms of physical damage resistance. I can't see anything in the scene that implies a NWC advantage over the Senshi.
Ranma has taken hits from Tatewaki's wooden sword, and it cut stone last time I checked. Kuno was going for a kill to free the Pigtailed Girl in about the first or second manga.
Exactly. A weapon attack--like from Kuno's sword--
can injure Ranma. So the question becomes: how do Crow's whip strikes compare to Kuno's sword strikes?
Well, we can't know for certain... but Kuno's sword doesn't really knock Ranma around very much at all, while the whip strikes seem to be powerful enough to send the Senshi
flying bodily. Thus, if you're looking to do a crossover analysis, a rather reasonable thing to do would be to decide that Crow's strikes are in fact far
more damaging than Kuno's--which gives you an instance of the Senshi weathering blows of Ranmaverse-or-greater power.
So the senshi take energy blast that can throw things through wall? I don't remember that ever happening, let alone without the senshi being at least out of the fight. The senshi can't take a flame trower(or was the flame buster a vortext cannon?) that could not melt stone, and Ranmma can stand up to Saffron's flame that can. The Ki blast(magical attacks if you ask me) throw people throught stone walls.
Actually, when Saffron melts the rock, it's with a blast he makes lower down in the tornado, which melts the rock down there, and then sends it spewing upward at Ranma. Ranma, for his part, uses a boulder that he iced with the Gekkaja to shield himself from said lava. He never actually withstands rock-melting temperatures himself, not without the help of doll-Akane or the magical-cold artifact.
In fact, Akane has to act as a human shield to keep him alive against Saffron's blasts even
before Saffron's heat hits the rock-melting point.
Speaking of heat, don't forget that kinetic force is
not the be-all and end-all of damage types. True, Sailor Moon universe attacks might not punch people through walls as often as Ranma's do--but that'll be of small comfort to someone whose body has been engulfed in, say, magical napalm from a Fire Soul or some such attack.
Really, quite a few of the SM-universe spells seem to be more contact effects, or cutting/piercing attacks, rather than any attempt at "blowing someone away". I don't have a comprehensive enough knowledge to authoritatively speak to the percentage, but it definitely seems to be a fairly large one.
Until I can get a different screen to appear I will have to assume she made it out like any normal human could have.
The main page I got them from is here:
http://soul-hunter.com/sailormoon/galleryscreencaps/042/index5.phpAlthough this one includes a play-by-play that gives a better sense of the timing:
http://www.anime-online.com/minako/svepisode/episode8.htmlApparently, the grenade landed at her feet, and took out the entire
warehouse when it blew.
Climhazard wrote:Well, they have some pretty nifty resistance against energy. And some good resistance to physical damage. But last IMO not as strong as NWC. But energy resistance clearly better that NWC's.
Yeah, that's pretty much how I think I'd play it if I were doing a crossover. Corresponding edges--the Senshi have better spell resistance, not so good impact resistance, and vice versa. But I'd keep the difference--in both directions--small enough that each team can spar meaningfully with each other on both levels.
I doubt I'd have any of the Senshi be quite able to beat Ranma in a straight one-on-one (except Moon in her Princess form, of course) but I'd have at least Jupiter and Uranus make him really work for it. And there
certainly wouldn't be any of the "godlike-Ranma owns all the Senshi simultaneously" stuff you see paraded around from time to time.
But that's just my personal spin. The kind of discussion we're doing here is fun enough, but to really go all the way and put an
actual crossover into effect you've got to make so many conversion decisions and decide on subtle nuances that there really is no way to definitively and rigorously "prove" in a context like this. Not to mention that no series is even perfectly
self-consistent, least of all a comedy like Ranma.
In the end, it leaves all kinds of room for interpretation, and for power scales sliding all over the place. And I think that's a
good thing. It allows you to frame your fic in whatever direction you need to. Do you need to have the NWC beating up the Senshi? Do you need to have the Senshi beating up the NWC? Having the freedom to pull either from the canon, depending on the needs of your story, is very nice.
In fact, I sometimes wonder if, instead of trying to come to an
answer in discussions like these, we shouldn't instead be searching for points of
ambiguity, and ways to further
muddy the waters within the context of canon...