




Shanami wrote:While I can see how Ranma might have been able to attend school semi-regularly not being completely discounted by the training trip, there is also significant evidence that he did not truly attend schools on a completely regular basis. There's simply not enough time in the Japanese school system to have enough breaks for the different trainings that Ranma went through. Unlike the US system, they have a lot less vacation time, and the Neko-ken training alone had to take a few weeks. We also have to get Ranma on top of mountains for the lion's cub training, to a swamp for the thing with the wolves and couch (and correct me if I'm wrong, but wolves are not native to Japan).
Genma gets a job within the first volume of the manga, and keeps it till after Shampoo arrives. With Tofu vanishing, either he lost it, or remained working but Tofu was no longer included. Ranma is seen with a handful of jobs throughout the series. Genma sold Ranma one time to Ukyo's father. If I remember correctly, even in the anime he only sold him two more times, one of which was during their time in Nerima.They would have had to move around a whole heck of a lot to get Ranma into the different locations for Genma to sell him, and by all indications Genma is a thief and would have had to run from the law repeatedly since there is rarely a point in the manga that implies that he worked regularly. With regard to the school uniform, there's a good chance that it was stolen.
But, more importantly, Ranma seems to only *remember* 2 friends from all his time growing up, being Ukyo and Ryoga. If he had an even decent education, he would certainly have had more schoolmates that he was willing to associate with. I mean, Ranma is by no means antisocial in the canon.
I just don't see it as feasible that Ranma managed to attend school even remotely full time based on the events we know happened and the amount of training that is implied to have happened. Japanese schools are quite insane in terms of workload, and Ranma would not have had time to train to the extent he did as a full time student.

LawOhki wrote:Ranma likely had a rather normal schooling, education wise. We know that Ranma had a school uniform while he went with Ryoga. Those aren't cheap, and would be a good indication that Genma took his schooling seriously. Being the cheap ass that he is, would Genma really drop down money for a uniform, and then on top of that pay for Ranma to be in high school if he didn't think it was important?
Crescent, please provide some evidence that they were constantly moving around besides Ranma asking "School?" I mean, really at that point he was outwardly focused on going back to China for a cure, not remaining in Nerima to be engaged to Akane. If he really didn't want to go, why didn't he complain more? This actually works as evidence that Genma would send Ranma to school whenever they were in one place, it's normal, so he goes along with it.

'Voyage'Crescent Pulsar R wrote:The evidence is right at the beginning, when Soun tells his daughters that Genma had taken his son on a voyage of training. A voyage is a long journey, usually to different or foreign places.
You do know that the ocean is only an hour or so train ride from Nerima, right? I was just there in August and took that train trip.Not only does the trip to China provide evidence that their training took them to foreign places, but the first chapter of the story where Genma realizes that Ranma has become stronger than him also shows at least one area that couldn't have taken place in Nerima: when he was eating Ranma's food by the ocean.
Watermelon Island happens during Highschool and isn't applicable to the current topic of Ranma not going to school due to the 10 year training trip. Also, you have to remember that training in the mountains is easy enough, taking a day of traveling at maximum to get to them, less if they lived nearby while on the 'training voyage'.And seeing as, during the series, they've trained in remote areas (the manga even provides odd places of training for people to go to, like watermelon island), it goes without saying that they would have done the same during their training trip.

All he said was "school?" that is hardly him going one way or the other. Genma justifies it by saying how they'll be there a while, with the hint hint that Akane would be there as well. Ranma doesn't argue with Genma about it, he just goes, he even has a backpack. Ranma's rather vocal if he doesn't want to do something, why wouldn't he raise a fuss?Crescent Pulsar R wrote:If he thought it was important, he would have responded as if it were, not as if he should because they would be in the area for too long. What that suggests is that, if he had any reason for Ranma to go to school, before high school, it was probably to avoid getting in trouble with the law. And, as you say, he's a cheapskate, so Shanami is probably right about him stealing a uniform.
And plenty of college students pay large sums of money for classes and go goof off in them, so what if Ranma occasionally gets distracted? Without looking up specific incidents, I would also wager that the events you're talking about take place between classes.Speaking of which, he didn't even bother with that when it was time for high school, and neither did Ranma care for wearing a uniform, either. He doesn't seem to take school all that seriously, either, since he would bother to eat during class, and other such things. Sure, the teacher at the time was easy to distract, but if he cared, if his father instilled a sense of importance in school work, he would have tried to get the class in order so he could get a proper education.
That's because of a poor translation. Ranma really comments on how he did well, and Genma chastises him for his ego. Akane by comparison got an average grade. Your comment also forgets how Ranma was initially unconcerned that he could get a grade that would embarrass him until Hinako couldn't back him up.As for a possible insight into his grades, he thought his test score would have been worse (when it was broadcast on TV), but Genma still smacked him on the back of the head and told him to show some shame, anyway. Which suggests that his grades are, most likely, routinely low.
The evidence is right at the beginning, when Soun tells his daughters that Genma had taken his son on a voyage of training. A voyage is a long journey, usually to different or foreign places. Not only does the trip to China provide evidence that their training took them to foreign places, but the first chapter of the story where Genma realizes that Ranma has become stronger than him also shows at least one area that couldn't have taken place in Nerima: when he was eating Ranma's food by the ocean. And seeing as, during the series, they've trained in remote areas (the manga even provides odd places of training for people to go to, like watermelon island), it goes without saying that they would have done the same during their training trip.


Konsaki wrote: 'Voyage'
Noun--a course of travel or passage, esp. a long journey by water to a distant place.
Noun--a passage through air or space, as a flight in an airplane or space vehicle.
Noun--a journey or expedition from one place to another by land.
Noun--Often, voyages. journeys or travels as the subject of a written account, or the account itself: the voyages of Marco Polo.
Noun--an enterprise or undertaking. (Obsolete but probably still applicable during the creation of the manga/translation)
Verb--to make or take a voyage; travel; journey.
Definition doesn't provide evidence that Genma excessively moved around, keeping Ranma from school.
You do know that the ocean is only an hour or so train ride from Nerima, right? I was just there in August and took that train trip.
Add in the fact that Ranma probably didn't grow up in Nerima, barring a short stint in the Boy's school which probably had him traveling in from a neighboring ward.
Watermelon Island happens during Highschool and isn't applicable to the current topic of Ranma not going to school due to the 10 year training trip. Also, you have to remember that training in the mountains is easy enough, taking a day of traveling at maximum to get to them, less if they lived nearby while on the 'training voyage'.
Keep in mind that not everyone in Japan lives in the Tokyo metro area...
LawOhki wrote:All he said was "school?" that is hardly him going one way or the other. Genma justifies it by saying how they'll be there a while, with the hint hint that Akane would be there as well. Ranma doesn't argue with Genma about it, he just goes, he even has a backpack. Ranma's rather vocal if he doesn't want to do something, why wouldn't he raise a fuss?
And plenty of college students pay large sums of money for classes and go goof off in them, so what if Ranma occasionally gets distracted? Without looking up specific incidents, I would also wager that the events you're talking about take place between classes.
That's because of a poor translation. Ranma really comments on how he did well, and Genma chastises him for his ego. Akane by comparison got an average grade. Your comment also forgets how Ranma was initially unconcerned that he could get a grade that would embarrass him until Hinako couldn't back him up.


Crescent Pulsar R wrote:The other thing is that the "correct" translation doesn't make any sense. How could the translators have gotten "be a man and show some shame, will you," wrong? I mean, "be a man and show some humility, will you?" That doesn't sound right. It makes more sense for Ranma to say that he didn't do as badly as he expected, because it's usually a bad score, and Genma hitting him and saying to show some shame because, despite the score not being as low as Ranma expected (and, perhaps, a score that he himself is satisfied with), it's still low according to the standard or average.
That's a very irresponsible response. I pointed out one scenario where he did it, where he could have decided to help get the class started, and he didn't. What does that say about him and what he thinks of his studies? What, the one time I pointed out was just a lark, or a day when he suffered from multiple-personality disorder, or is it not an acceptable example of what kind of personality he has, and how he applies himself to his school work?
And I'm just taking a shot in the dark, here, but wouldn't refusing to wear a uniform be a act/sign of rebellion?
When during the year Genma took Ranma out of that school is never specified, only that it was after Ryoga had challenged him to a duel, or when Ranma arrives at Furinkan, though that is about ~1-2weeks after Jusenkyo, I don't remember which specifically at the moment. And Jusenkyo was if I remember correctly was about 1 month after leaving school, it's hard to remember were this was mentioned, since most of the time references for this were just "training period".Also, from the events with Ryoga, it is clear that Genma didn't care about removing Ranma from school at random points in time. They leave in the middle of the semester according to what I remember

But, more importantly, Ranma seems to only *remember* 2 friends from all his time growing up, being Ukyo and Ryoga. If he had an even decent education, he would certainly have had more schoolmates that he was willing to associate with. I mean, Ranma is by no means antisocial in the canon.
before high school, it was probably to avoid getting in trouble with the law.
because Ranma asks because he didn't expect it, so it wasn't a normal, and thus expected, occurrence.
I pointed out one scenario where he did it, where he could have decided to help get the class started, and he didn't. What does that say about him and what he thinks of his studies?
Is there actually any evidence that Ranma had been to Nerima prior to the events of the series? I know he was able to lead Ryoga to Ryoga's house, but wasn't that in another area (they did hitch a ride on a train to get there), meaning Ranma may have come close to Nerima while attending Junior High School, but didn't neccessarily come to Nerima itself?
And maybe he doesn't, since his classmates (who may or may not have been under the wrong impression, regarding Ranma's actions) had to ask the time that he had ever cared about his grades.
he thought his test score would have been worse (when it was broadcast on TV)

LawOhki wrote:Very easily, the ranmascan translators threw in references and things that weren't there, it still doesn't change what was originally said.
That's a perfectly valid response, you made a big point on how Ranma not going around and being a perfect student shows that he doesn't give a damn about schooling. And now you're claiming that because Ranma didn't get everyone else in line that also means he doesn't care about schooling.
Ranma likely had a rather normal schooling, education wise. We know that Ranma had a school uniform while he went with Ryoga. Those aren't cheap, and would be a good indication that Genma took his schooling seriously. Being the cheap ass that he is, would Genma really drop down money for a uniform, and then on top of that pay for Ranma to be in high school if he didn't think it was important?
You didn't point out any times, just a vague suggestion that Ranma would take advantage of a lax teacher, chapters and pages please.
three headed dog wrote:At what point in the manga or even the anime has Genma ever cared about the law?
I don't get this line of reasoning. Ranma didn't expect it not because it wasn't common but because he was still thinking they'd only stay a little while and then leave to try and find a cure in my opinion.
Ranma is extremely competitive and does care about his image. For him to do poorly would be out of character since that would make people think he is dumb (something Ranma would do basically anything to avoid people thinking). In Japan, in real life and pretty much every anime involving schools like Kare Kano (His and her circumstances) or Azumanga daoih, the schools post the students test grades on the walls so the students should have an idea as to where Ranma ranks in the class scholastically (besides students often look at other students grades to compare everywhere).
That is only because the principal implied they were bad. Everything I see points out to him doing at least average like his not caring at first if the principal read them out (since they would not be all that bad) and his statement about how it is impossible he does worse than Tatewaki.

Return to Specific Series: Ranma
Users browsing this forum: No registered users