Yeah... well except maybe if you get them to form a degenerate matter... well after some short looking the best I could find was that you could get Hydrogen to crystallize under extreme pressures, though this is probably more applicable to Jupiter then the Sun. Some further searching turned up
this, where the relevant portion notes that white dwarfs are crystalline in nature, once you get past the atmosphere.
Still, considering that stellar cores don't seem all to friendly to degenerate matter, I suspect you are right in that getting any thing to form in an active star for long is pretty hopeless. Though most likely the Helium Flash, mentioned earlier in this thread, does have a brief degenerate phase. Which I guess would imply that for a brief moment even stars you can sometimes crystallize some atomic matter. So yeah... insanity, and does this mean that we've just surpassed the improbable and all that.
Worst of all, that temporary degenerate matter phase in the star would probably in part be crystalline Helium. Yeah... I want my godhood.
