by Wyrd » Mon Mar 28, 2011 9:00 pm
Actually, I've argued before that the Jedi do not follow the light side of the force. The Sith and the Jedi both preach that all positive emotions are a weakness. The Jedi say they are a weakness because they can lead to dark emotions and thus the dark side, and the Sith say that only aggression and ambition are worthwhile. Confidence might not be completely on the light side, especially since Ranma does take it to the point of arrogance, but the Jedi were rather guilty of arrogance as well, and learning how much more there is out there than he ever imagined could be the first step to guiding Ranma to a healthy relationship with the force.
Both the Jedi and Sith path are corruptions of the philosophy of the open palm and the philosophy of the closed fist. The open palm teaches connection with everything around you and putting others before self, while the closed fist teaches that each individual needs to find their own strength and that weakness, especially in yourself, cannot be tolerated, putting self before others.
Something that never seems to occur to the Jedi is why the force needed to be brought back in balance in the first place. According to the cosmology of the Star Wars Universe(excepting what George Lucas has done to screw with it since he started taking a personal interest in it again), the Jedi and the Sith were once one order that had a split millenia ago over disputes about the place of emotion in the force. The faction that supported use of emotion instead of suppression of it left/was exiled(depending on the telling) and wound up finding the homeworld of the Sith race. They had been practicing an emotion based version of force control for a very long time, but their focus on the strength of the individual and other cultural issues tainted what these former jedi learned from them.