
Mr L wrote:Fellow's point is that since the youma, who were all evil, were brought back to life, why should these two be excluded?

claymade wrote:Indeed, the Wish definitely was selective... but on the other hand, Lesp and Cortheia weren't really particularly good either. The closest thing they really had to a redeeming feature was they had something besides themselves they did actually care about, but that much could be said for Kunzite, for Zoisite, for Beryl herself, and even for an infamous European dictator who I'll not name for fear of invoking the specter of Goodwin. The two youma were, in the end, unapologetically out to dominate, enslave and feed off of all humanity down to the last man, woman and child, and they never really had the slightest qualm about that part of things. So it'd be hard to have a criteria for Usagi's wish that'd bring those two back without bringing back pretty close to everybody on the Dark Kingdom side along with.
Which isn't to say it couldn't work that way; I can totally buy that her Wish (potentially) might've wanted to do exactly that. Or not, depending on how it worked, and how much juice she was able to put into it.
But in deciding between the two ways it could have gone, it's just that each person added to the mix: Nephrite, Kunzite, Zoisite, Beryl, Darkmistress... they all become extra plot threads that I'd have to resolve. Bringing them back would put me in the position of either trying to sweep them all back under the rug again quickly in a way that has minimal story impact (which feels kinda meh: "oh yeah, btw, they came back to life! and then died again, which is why they aren't actually around.") or actually dealing with those plot threads in a more thorough way in a cast that's already oversaturated with characters. I mean, think about what a huge impact, even just in terms of character interactions and such, that Beryl alone being alive would bring.
I'd have to address it. Worse, I'd have to address it in ways that feel appropriate and fitting to the level of impact characters like that would have. It's a can of worms--granted, a potentially fascinating can of worms what with how she'd interact with Serenity and Endymion now--but a huge can of worms nonetheless. Just because something is a really fascinating concept in isolation doesn't mean it won't cause problems for the larger fic if included.
Now take that, and multiply it by just about every Dark Kingdom character who died in the series. I mean, heck, look at how long the chapters are getting already, with just the plot threads that are being juggled right now, and I've actually cut several plot threads already from my original outline.
I'll keep the concept in mind, and see if anything germinates in my thought process that would make it click... but right now it just seems a LOT of plot overhead to incur for the end result of giving Lesp and Cortheia a cameo. Even as enjoyable as they were to write.


Fellow Sufferer wrote:I get what you're saying. Well, I just felt like tossing a few ideas your way, to hear your thoughts. It'd be nice if they were actually helpful, but I'll take what I can get %).
(grumbles) I really should stop with my endless notes I write and finally produce some actual (fan)fiction of my own. That'll cure me from my urge to meddle, hopefully.
Mr L wrote:Oh, I thought they were all dead in the final battle. So, the youma experimented from Kazuo's organization were simple survivors?


Blackcat101 wrote:So, I am guessed Ranma cursed gets locked and he also gets brainwashed... not that the idea was to get his curse locked, it was just a side-effect (Plus is always kind of funny)
Think about it, The Senshi would be confused about being attacked by a strange redhead... since they never fought Ranma cursed form...


Users browsing this forum: No registered users