
Like I said I don't think Nodoka can do what she would need to do as the kaishakunin because of her lack of skill with a sword.lwf58 wrote:A kaishaku's job isn't to just cut off the person's head if they are about to embarrass themselves by crying out in pain. They were usually the person's best friend, and their job was to end the agony when they judged that the person had suffered enough to expiate whatever sin they had committed.
In the case of the nobility, the kaishaku ended it as soon as the person had completed the ritual cut prescribed by custom.
The instances where a person lived for days after an attempt at harakiri was when the person had no kaishaku - which was a punishment for someone who had completely disgraced himself and his clan.
Second, a kaishaku was not supposed to actually cut off the person's head. That was deemed a grave dishonor to the person. The cut was about 1/2 to 3/4 of the way through the neck, doing the job and severing the spine, but leaving the head attached to the body for the funeral.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaishaku
Note: Women are forbidden to commit seppuku by harakiri. They were only allowed to use a tanto or kaiken to cut their throats in a ceremony called jigai. Note that part of the ritual was to tie the legs together in such a way that death throes would not leave the body in an unsightly position.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jigai
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seppuku



Necavit wrote:You know the problem with justifying one act with another?
Ranma being Ryoga's sister was revenge for Ryoga tricking him.
Ryoga tricking him was revenge for the curse. When you begin to justify one act with another, all it does it lead to a back and forth.
Two wrongs dont make a right, right?
This is more or less only half true. Ranma has done very little to Ryoga on purpose.Necavit wrote: simple truth is that neither Ranma nor Ryoga are guiltless in their rivalry. Both have done some underhanded and low things.
Necavit wrote: do you figure that Ryoga and Mousse wanted to kill Ranma in the Herb arc. They hit him on the head, thats their attempt at murder? It was low, no doubt, but no murder. And Id say saving Ranma's life from Herb (an actual attempt at muder) was Rumiko's way of providing redmeption.
Necavit wrote: to your ps, you really think Ryoga's threat to kill Ranma is over bread? You dont think that its boiled up rage over the curse that is than spilled over onto the easy target of Ranma?
Or do you mean chasing Ranma down? Well when your only friend leaves, and you spend your life wandering and have nothing better to do, why not follow him? The whole Im going to kill Ranma only comes after hes cursed.




Her motivation seems more duty and talent and fear of what Akane would do if someone else needed to do it than any sort of selfless feelings or desire to aid others
Usually when Akane helps Ranma she needs him to be in a somehow vulnerable position and she likes rubbing it in, and it is about stroking her own ego and proving her abilities.
Even some of the nastier things Ranma has done are for the sake of others, such as pretending to be Ryoga's sister in order to prevent him from taking advantage of Akane and Akari at the same time,
I also think that the way Ranma chooses to deal with some Ryoga incidents, by disguising herself as Ryoga's fiancee or sister, rather than just outing him or fighting him over it, displays a certain care for Ryoga, if in a warped fashion, Ranma would rather play as someone who cares for Ryoga than fight him over things openly.



Necavit wrote:So lets have a chat with Pulsar.
Ive learned over the years some people dont like Ryoga, fine, I cant change that. We could argue back and forth about Ranma did this and Ryoga did that, but I stick to my statement that they have both been jerks.
Heres my one prob with your post.
Do you admit that Ranma is the cause of Ryoga's curse? Plain and simple, if you agree to that I dont see the need to argue.
And if you agree to that. While it may be an accident. Ranma shows no remorse. If someone cursed me to turn into a pig, I think I might hold a grudge.
As for selfish and self centered, "Shrugs" I can call Ranma selfish and self centered. We can both show evidence that Ranma and Ryoga are and are not, or we could just say that all the characters have good and bad moments.
And both Ranma and Ryoga are basically good guys at heart.
I just get annoyed when people crucify Ryoga for his bad deeds, and forget or justfiy Ranma's bad deeds.




Return to Specific Series: Ranma
Users browsing this forum: No registered users