by SpaceKnight of Chaos » Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:18 pm
Does Ranma love to train, or does he do it simply because he literally can't afford to rest on his laurels? There's evidence either way, and I'm not trying to pick a fight, I'm just pointing that out.
Also, Genma would be able to force Ranma to do something against his will... how? All it takes is one dose of the Satsu, and Genma's too weak to move or speak, let alone browbeat Ranma into doing something. That's probably why Hinako is the way she is, in canon, come to think of it... but that's off topic.
Yes, there are stupid occurences and accidents, but there's stupid, and then there's stupid. Assuming Genma falls in first, the odds are likely that Ranma will suck him dry and render him too weak to push Ranma off of his perch. Then, having seen and heard just what sort of weirdness Jusenkyo is capable of, Ranma would move away from Jusenkyo- and between him being too weak at first to try and push Ranma in, and then calming down enough not to want to (especially if the Guide brings up there's at least one "Drowned Woman" type spring, which Genma believes would put them in deep crap with Nodoka), Genma wouldn't try to push Ranma in either. Yes, Ranma could slip and fall in, or the banks could give way, or the bamboo he's standing on could break, but that's going to be tricky to pull off and have it come off as believable, even if he doesn't fall into the canonical Nyanniichuan.
What I'm trying to say is that the problem is less Ranma being cursed and more "Ranma getting cursed without it seeming like the Voodoo Shark"... well, that's the politest interpretation, even if not quite accurate.
Come to think of it, whether Ranma gets cursed or not, there's going to be an inevitable change in the way Ryoga gets cursed. In canon, Ranma has no choice but to chase Genma down in order to beat him up- here, the angry Ranma can and will simply pull out a 50 yen piece, suck Genma dry, and then literally kick him while he's down... which means he isn't going to bump into Ryoga. Although... given where he was wandering, and it was actually the cliffside crumbling under his fingers when he landed that made him fall, he could still fall in off his own accord, and it would be in character for him to blame this on Ranma anyway- it just means Ranma won't feel any accord to not just blurt out Ryoga's secret.
Water, water, everywhere, and all was cursed and black!
Drowned ones cast bad spell and out come pig, girl, duck, panda!
Swirl, swirl, slithery pond, and join with magic spring!
Swirl, swirl, dirty pond, and rid the cursed sting!
Here my prayer, I beg you please!
Now turn these curses BACK!
http://www.issendai.com/rpgs/japanese-boys-names.shtml
http://www.issendai.com/rpgs/japanese-girls-names.shtml